My Own Party

Comments

I agree with you and really like your platform. It's actually a truer "left" platform than the "pretend leftist" Democrats. Currently, the Green Party has a platform that seems pretty similar. I voted for Ralph Nader (nominee of the Green Party) in the 2000 election. He captured about 3% of the popular vote in that election. In 2004, he ran as an Independent.

I bet you that most Americans have never even heard of Nader or his influence on the 2000 presidential election. The Greens are still trying to run for president in the 2008 election.

Which brings up the biggest hindrance to our democratic process: the lack of an independent media. We do not hear about candidates such as Ralph Nader because the media only sparsely covered him in 2000. And when they did cover him, they didn't refer to him as Ralph Nader, candidate for President...they referred to him as "the Nader factor."

More of the "Nader factor" can be found at the following:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A52671-2004Oct21.html
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9E05EFD91739F932A15750C0A960958260
http://www.commondreams.org/headlines/081200-05.htm
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_kmnew/is_200404/ai_n6834400
http://media.www.mcquadrangle.org/media/storage/paper663/news/2004/09/29/News/The-Nader.Factor-734019.shtml

I voted Nader in 2004, and I agree with the Green Party. However I think we need a new candidate who does not have the negative name recognition of Nader, who is stigmatized as a defeated candidate and seen as siphoning votes from Democrats, thus handing the election to Bush. I also believe there are a fair few "conservative" votes up for grabs by emphasizing reforms and sticking it to Republicans for their lack of fiscal responsibility. Regardless, instant run-off voting is a necessary first step to mounting a credible third-party challenge. Independents need to focus on changing election laws in referendum states.

With respect to plank 1 of your platform:

- eliminating electoral collages and reforming the voting system seems like a good idea. As a non-American, the electoral college system seems incredibly exciting but is only comprehensible as a result of watching The West Wing. We have a lower house with preferential voting, which as a consequence is essentially dominated by 2 parties, but an upper house with proportional representation. Proportional voting / representation helps with the problem of "vote wasting" and two party dominance and givesminor parties get a look in, so instant run-off voting sounds pretty good too.

- I don't know how I feel about your system of appointing Supreme Court judges. Although the independence of judges could arguably be criticised on the grounds of their being appointed by politicians, their independence would be even further threatened if they were to be elected by the public. My concern would be that it would lead to tyranny of the majority - many of the most unpopular court decisions have been those which protect the rights of minorities. I'm not sure, but I think that the US still doesn't have mandatory retirement ages for judges? If not, they should. Although my favourite Australian High Court judge is about to fall victim to one when he is still performing brilliantly, they definitely help to prevent the judiciary from becoming too "stale" (for want of a nicer term).

Thanks - you've given me a lot to think about.

I like your ideas a lot, its a shame more people like you aren't involved in American politics. As I'm from Britain your government is different from mines but I do agree with a lot of your logical suggestions.

I think a key thing for America is to come off its high horse and mix it with the rest of the world, as a non-American I can say a lot of people are tired of American arrogance (not an insult, please don't take it that way) America is still a powerful country but all the power is focused on the wrong things.

Especially with the cold war bubbling back into the world of politics I think it is time for America to get back on favourable terms with the rest of the world. But a great post and I'll be checking the rest.

Mark
[this is good]
I like your ideas a lot, its a shame more people like you aren't involved in American politics. As I'm from Britain your government is different from mines but I do agree with a lot of your logical suggestions.

I think a key thing for America is to come off its high horse and mix it with the rest of the world, as a non-American I can say a lot of people are tired of American arrogance (not an insult, please don't take it that way) America is still a powerful country but all the power is focused on the wrong things.

Especially with the cold war bubbling back into the world of politics I think it is time for America to get back on favourable terms with the rest of the world. But a great post and I'll be checking the rest.

Mark
[this is good]
I'm hoping we can discuss this platform having a brazilian coffee someday. :) It would be lovely...

xxx
Moi
Carbon tax over carbon trading. And you'd probably have my vote, except I'd never get a chance to vote for you. There is such an immense level of both selfishness and shortsightedness that things like increased gas tax will never be popular, no matter how much sense they make. And then there is the religious question. But if you get on a ballot, I'll check the box.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in