Almost Worse Than Nothing
Over dinner this evening with a couple first-years on their way back from Oxford, where we each ordered huge, bloody steaks and whiskey, and where my view of whatever college basketball game happened to be showing on TV was obstructed by the three large boars’ heads mounted on the wall, the question came up as to whether we “believe in Teacher Corps.” My answer, anyway, is no. I don’t believe in Teacher Corps, not because it does no good at all, but because it is too minuscule for such an enormous problem. We have a problem with education in this country that we need to solve. Programs like Teacher Corps allow legislatures and the general public to salve their collective conscience, reassuring themselves that they are doing something about a problem which in fact requires several orders of magnitude more investment than they are willing to sacrifice. This is like that TV commercial where the engineer tries to patch a leak in a dam with a wad of gum, followed by the admonition, “Assuming you’ve done enough for retirement doesn’t make much sense either.” When public education fails, the apathy and selfish, conceited ignorance of the voting public is ultimately to blame, and no Mississippi Teacher Corps can solve the problem or absolve the responsibility.
Comments
Do we honestly believe that when our students see our shining privileged faces in August they think, "At last! Someone has come to help me!" (If we do, our conceit is beyond measure.) Those who do think this already have hope.
It is we, not they, who need the hope we bring.
So do I believe in Teacher Corps? Isn't that a bit like believing in gravity? Teacher Corps is here and is doing whatever each of us is doing. I do believe that one child's life has been changed. And that's really all I need to believe right now.
Except, perhaps, also that there is very little that bloody meat, whiskey, and good conversation won't cure.
My point is a politcal one, not a personal one. In the grand course of history, for a few of us to pat ourselves on the back and say, well, we tried, is not really good enough because the war is being lost. Teacher Corps is insignificant and, yes, futile, becuase it is inadequate for the problem and the model is not scalable to match the size of the problem. Not even Teach for America, despite its size, is scalable to the numbers needed. And it's not just a numbers problem. The whole Rent-A-Teacher paradigm is inadequate to seriously improve the teaching profession.